Several people have not turned in the Crime Types paper and need to do so ASAP. The clock is ticking.... Remember, I take one point off per day if something is late and you have no legitimate excuse for it being late. Also, you should be reading Tulia. I began to talk about it in class this past Tuesday. We will cover the whole of this book before all is said and done for the semester. And for the sake of ESSAY III, you need to read well into it. That essay will be due on the first class after the break.
On Tuesday 11/25 I will show the documentary on Tulia. It is pretty good, but by no means a substitute for the comprehensive coverage of this case in the book you are reading. To earn 4 points extra credit (which many of you could use), I want you to write a one-page response to seeing the documentary in which I want you to comment on the documentary as a whole and bring out ONE point where the book provides more detail or background on any aspect of this documentary. If you choose to do this, it will be due NO LATER THAN THE FIRST CLASS AFTER THE BREAK (Tues. 12/2).
Friday, November 21, 2008
Monday, November 17, 2008
Drug War Video, Tulia, & ESSAY III
Instead of posting my follow-up comments on the drug war video we saw, I'll take some time out to highlight some points in class on Tuesday (11/18). We will also begin to talk about Tulia. You need to start reading that. I plan to cover it all before the semester is over. Also, as you can see below, the topic of your final out-of-class essay deals with Tulia.
__________________________
Sociology 220
Essay III
11/17/08
A. In the context of the early trials and convictions, which carried exceedingly long sentences (basically up to Part Three, p. 179), I want you to write an essay on how such a miscarriage of justice was possible in the first place. Specifically, I want you to identify and discuss any TWO factors which contributed to this miscarriage of justice. And between these two factors, which ONE do you believe represents the greatest threat to the proper functioning of our court system in general. (Note: you do not necessarily have to read all the way through p. 179 in order to complete this assignment.)
B. The essay should be roughly 3 pages. Be sure to indicate the page number(s) of any passage(s) from the book which you quote in your essay.
C. This essay is due on TUESDAY, DEC. 2ND, which is the first class after we come back from Thanksgiving break. This essay is worth 25 points.
__________________________
I will be handing back essay II on Tuesday (11/18). For those who have not yet turned that essay in, tomorrow will be the deadline to get it in.
Also, don't forget that the Crime Types Paper is due on Thursday (11/20), at which time each of you will be called on to give a brief overview of your paper in class.
__________________________
Sociology 220
Essay III
11/17/08
A. In the context of the early trials and convictions, which carried exceedingly long sentences (basically up to Part Three, p. 179), I want you to write an essay on how such a miscarriage of justice was possible in the first place. Specifically, I want you to identify and discuss any TWO factors which contributed to this miscarriage of justice. And between these two factors, which ONE do you believe represents the greatest threat to the proper functioning of our court system in general. (Note: you do not necessarily have to read all the way through p. 179 in order to complete this assignment.)
B. The essay should be roughly 3 pages. Be sure to indicate the page number(s) of any passage(s) from the book which you quote in your essay.
C. This essay is due on TUESDAY, DEC. 2ND, which is the first class after we come back from Thanksgiving break. This essay is worth 25 points.
__________________________
I will be handing back essay II on Tuesday (11/18). For those who have not yet turned that essay in, tomorrow will be the deadline to get it in.
Also, don't forget that the Crime Types Paper is due on Thursday (11/20), at which time each of you will be called on to give a brief overview of your paper in class.
Monday, November 10, 2008
Family Questions on Crime Types' Reports for the Final Exam
Below are the questions from the families, as promised. But you will note that I have done some editing. Also, some of you asked questions based more on my follow-up comments than your reports. You should have focused just on your reports. Finally, I probably should have asked you to come up with more than two questions so I could have selected two good ones from several, but I didn't, which is "my bad," I guess. Nonetheless, here they are:
Green Family: Chapter 2: Homicide and Assault
1. What types of murders does Cooney say constitute the majority of murders, as Dabney brings out in the Introduction to this chapter? (1)
ANSWER: Moralistic murders with expressive motives that are committed by novices in the heat of the moment. That is, "crimes of passion."
2. Identify and briefly describe ONE of the six possible rationalization frameworks battered women use to rationalize the behavior of their abusers. (2)
ANSWER: Any ONE of the following:
(1) appeal to the salvation ethic -- the woman feels the need to save the abuser.
(2) denial of the victimizer -- the woman sees the battering as an outside force beyond the control of their spouse and think it can be cured.
(3) denial of injury -- the experience is so out of sync with their expectations that they refuse to even acknowledge they've been hurt.
(4) denial of victimization -- the woman blames herself for the violence.
(5) denial of options -- referring to both practical and emotional options, the woman refuses to believe she has any other option than to stay with the abuser. Eg. that even a life being battered is better than being lonely and alone.
(6) appeal to higher loyalties -- the woman endures the abuse for the sake of a higher commitment, either religious or traditional.
Blue Family: Chapter 3: Violent Sex Crimes (Two family members submitted questions, so I simply selected the best two, which I also modified somewhat because most of the questions reflected my follow-up comments.)
1. Among the theories of rape mentioned in the Introduction to this chapter is the "gender inequality theory." Briefly describe this theory. (2)
ANSWER: "that rape and fear of rape enable men to assert their power over women and maintain the existing system of gender stratification (or inequality)." Rape is associated with strong patriarchal societies.
2. In the context of selection #8, "Understanding Women's Experiences of Wife Rape," what did I suggest in my follow-up comments was the "bottom line" with respect to preventing this type of rape especially? (1)
ANSWER: That men should be taught NOT to treat women as mere sex objects, even if they happen to be their wives.
Yellow family: Chapter 4: Robbery
1. How does robbery typically differ from other violent crimes such as murder, assault, and rape? (2)
ANSWER: In the case of robbery, the offender typically does NOT know the victim, as opposed to other violent crimes where there is often a previous relationship between the victim and the offender.
2. Identify ONE other possible motive, besides money, a robber may have. (1)
ANSWER: Any ONE of the capitalized terms: Expressive motives such as REVENGE, or a quest for EXCITEMENT and SENSORY STIMULATION.
Black family: Chapter 5: Burglary
1. In the context of Chapter 5 on burglary and the discussion of the "stolen property system," briefly describe the role of the "fence." (2)
ANSWER: The role of the fence is to receive the goods which have been stolen and then attempt to sell them. He is essentially the "middle man" who specializes in buying and selling stolen goods which is indispensable for burglars.
2. Seasoned professional burglars engage in "search planning" in which they often rely on what type of information? (1)
ANSWER: A "tipster" who informs them of the suitability of various targets.
Red family: Chapter 7: Public Order Crime
1. Identify any TWO of the six "contingent elements of the prostitute's identity," as discussed in selection # 18, "An Analysis of Women's Involvement in Prostitution." (2)
ANSWER: Any TWO of the following:
(1) prostitutes-as-workers
(2) prostitutes-as-commodified bodies
(3) prostitutes-as-business-women
(4) prostitutes-as-loving-partners
(5) prostitutes-as-victims
(6) prostitutes-as-survivors
2. Briefly describe the "residence house" as one of the most common forms of crack houses in the Miami area. (1)
ANSWER: Residence houses are private homes where the owner welcomes in partiers for extended drug and sex fests.
_________________________________________
Finally, a quick reminder for tomorrow's class (Tues. 11/11) that your essays on "A Hard Straight" are due. If for some reason you have not seen it yet, remember it is available on reserve in the library.
Green Family: Chapter 2: Homicide and Assault
1. What types of murders does Cooney say constitute the majority of murders, as Dabney brings out in the Introduction to this chapter? (1)
ANSWER: Moralistic murders with expressive motives that are committed by novices in the heat of the moment. That is, "crimes of passion."
2. Identify and briefly describe ONE of the six possible rationalization frameworks battered women use to rationalize the behavior of their abusers. (2)
ANSWER: Any ONE of the following:
(1) appeal to the salvation ethic -- the woman feels the need to save the abuser.
(2) denial of the victimizer -- the woman sees the battering as an outside force beyond the control of their spouse and think it can be cured.
(3) denial of injury -- the experience is so out of sync with their expectations that they refuse to even acknowledge they've been hurt.
(4) denial of victimization -- the woman blames herself for the violence.
(5) denial of options -- referring to both practical and emotional options, the woman refuses to believe she has any other option than to stay with the abuser. Eg. that even a life being battered is better than being lonely and alone.
(6) appeal to higher loyalties -- the woman endures the abuse for the sake of a higher commitment, either religious or traditional.
Blue Family: Chapter 3: Violent Sex Crimes (Two family members submitted questions, so I simply selected the best two, which I also modified somewhat because most of the questions reflected my follow-up comments.)
1. Among the theories of rape mentioned in the Introduction to this chapter is the "gender inequality theory." Briefly describe this theory. (2)
ANSWER: "that rape and fear of rape enable men to assert their power over women and maintain the existing system of gender stratification (or inequality)." Rape is associated with strong patriarchal societies.
2. In the context of selection #8, "Understanding Women's Experiences of Wife Rape," what did I suggest in my follow-up comments was the "bottom line" with respect to preventing this type of rape especially? (1)
ANSWER: That men should be taught NOT to treat women as mere sex objects, even if they happen to be their wives.
Yellow family: Chapter 4: Robbery
1. How does robbery typically differ from other violent crimes such as murder, assault, and rape? (2)
ANSWER: In the case of robbery, the offender typically does NOT know the victim, as opposed to other violent crimes where there is often a previous relationship between the victim and the offender.
2. Identify ONE other possible motive, besides money, a robber may have. (1)
ANSWER: Any ONE of the capitalized terms: Expressive motives such as REVENGE, or a quest for EXCITEMENT and SENSORY STIMULATION.
Black family: Chapter 5: Burglary
1. In the context of Chapter 5 on burglary and the discussion of the "stolen property system," briefly describe the role of the "fence." (2)
ANSWER: The role of the fence is to receive the goods which have been stolen and then attempt to sell them. He is essentially the "middle man" who specializes in buying and selling stolen goods which is indispensable for burglars.
2. Seasoned professional burglars engage in "search planning" in which they often rely on what type of information? (1)
ANSWER: A "tipster" who informs them of the suitability of various targets.
Red family: Chapter 7: Public Order Crime
1. Identify any TWO of the six "contingent elements of the prostitute's identity," as discussed in selection # 18, "An Analysis of Women's Involvement in Prostitution." (2)
ANSWER: Any TWO of the following:
(1) prostitutes-as-workers
(2) prostitutes-as-commodified bodies
(3) prostitutes-as-business-women
(4) prostitutes-as-loving-partners
(5) prostitutes-as-victims
(6) prostitutes-as-survivors
2. Briefly describe the "residence house" as one of the most common forms of crack houses in the Miami area. (1)
ANSWER: Residence houses are private homes where the owner welcomes in partiers for extended drug and sex fests.
_________________________________________
Finally, a quick reminder for tomorrow's class (Tues. 11/11) that your essays on "A Hard Straight" are due. If for some reason you have not seen it yet, remember it is available on reserve in the library.
Tuesday, November 4, 2008
Just a Reminder
This morning (Tues. 11/4) we saw the documentary, "A Hard Straight". You need to check out my Wed., Oct. 29th blog post for a description of the essay I want you to write on it, which will be due next Tuesday, 11/11. This documentary will be available in the library if you missed it or want to see some of it again. Just go to the circulation desk. It will be for use only in the library.
As I also mentioned this morning, we will wrap up Crime Types, as well as start to get into the drug issue next Tuesday. And don't forget the paper assignment in which you need to locate, read, and analyze three outside articles related to a particular crime type, which will be due on the 20th.
As I also mentioned this morning, we will wrap up Crime Types, as well as start to get into the drug issue next Tuesday. And don't forget the paper assignment in which you need to locate, read, and analyze three outside articles related to a particular crime type, which will be due on the 20th.
Friday, October 31, 2008
Follow-ups to Chapter 7 & Chapter 5
Before I begin to re-cap these two chapters, let me, again, remind you to check out the description of the next essay assignment connected with the documentary I will be showing next Tuesday 11/4. That description can be found at the previous blog post, on Wed., Oct. 29th.
First, my comments on Chapter 7 which I did not get to yesterday in class:
#16 "Drugs-Crime Connections: Elaborations from the Life Histories of Hard Core Heroin Addicts"
A. Looks at the basic question: do drugs cause crime or does crime cause drugs?
1. Basically, addicts said their drug and criminal activities began independently, but eventually became intertwined, which makes sense.
B. Two general factors shape the drug and crime careers of respondents: (1) availability -- more you had, more you did; less available it was most addicts could adjust by reducing consumption. (2) life-structure -- "...regularly occuring patterns of daily domestic, occupational, recreational, or criminal activity."
C. The article makes an important point about when heroin becomes the most destructive -- when that larger "life-structure" is deteriorated. See middle paragraph on p. 274, under heading: The Free-Wheeling Junkie -- High Availability/Low Life Structure.
D. We must seek to improve that life structure -- sense of order and purpose -- to rehabilitate the heroin addict.
#17 "The Miami Sex-for-Crack Market Revisited"
A. No question that prostitution and crack cocaine use are related. Also includes a public health warning about having sex in some of these crack houses -- that they are at extreme risk of contracting HIV.
#18 "An Analysis of Women's Involvement in Prostitution"
A. This is an unpublished paper which I believe is poorly written, filled with jargon, and based on only 21 interviews.
B. One interesting point which was touched on in the class report is the irony of fining these women for their behavior. "Fining women involved in prostitution for their prostitution-related offenses is paradoxical. Many of them simply did not have the financial resources to pay their fines. The obvious irony is that the criminal justice system, itself, created the conditions that both justified these women's continued involvement in prostitution as well as trapped them within it" (p. 296)
Chapter 5 Burglary
A. Recent NCVS data suggest that crimes against property account for more than three-fourths of all criminal victimizations, and roughly one in six property crimes is a household burglary. Estimates indicate that 3,139,700 households were burglarized in 2001. Total of $2.9 billion in losses, not to mention the emotional trauma of the victims.
1. Yet the rate of burglary has dropped nearly 75% over the past three decades. In 1973 there were 110 per 1,000 households compared to 28.7 per 1,000 in 2001.
2. Perhaps surprisingly, the rural rate is higher than the suburban rate, which is the lowest. This is probably due to greater prevalence of neighborhood watch programs, more police patrols, in suburban areas. This lends credence to the routine activities theory. (see bottom, p. 172)
3. Also surprising, this is one crime where the U.S. compares favorably with many other countries. (see top, p. 173)
B. A significant point is that this type of crime also depends on a thriving UNDERGROUND ECONOMY, consisting of FENCES (people willing to handle stolen goods) and consumers willing to buy this stolen merchandise. (Flea markets are notorious for being places where stolen goods are sold.)
C. Under the "cognitive aspects of burglary," Dabney notes the "shallow instrumental motives" -- burglars become accustomed to a fast-paced lifestyle and/or are addicted to drugs "thus (they) continue to commit burglaries in the face of increasing risks and diminishing rewards." (p. 176)
1. Although obviously some planning is involved -- "Research indicates that most burglars engage in only minimal pre-event planning....Indeed, they tend to operate in a somewhat spontaneous fashion, exploiting opportunities as they arise." (p. 177)
2. 56% of incarcerated burglars in one survey were under the influence of drugs or alcohol at the time they committed their last offense. But a urinalysis of arrested offenders found 80% to have drugs or alcohol in their system.
a) Some use drugs to enhance their performance (botttom, p. 178), such as Malcolm X who talked about snorting cocaine before going out to burglarize.
3. Burglars tend to depend on others such as getting inside information about whether a home is vacant or what valuables might be in a home.
D. Arrest rate is only 13% (which might suggest the relevance of deterrence theory since the certainty of punishment in so low).
E. Informal controls (eg., neighborhood crime watch) are important to deter burglary activity. Even neighbors just getting together to clean up their neighborhood might send a deterrence message to would-be burglars.
#11 "A Woman's Place Is in the Home: Females and Residential Burglary"
A. Profiles female burglars who share a lot of the characteristics with males, but in some cases even more so -- eg., that they almost always work with others. Also, women tend to start at an older age than males.
B. Confirms an observation I made about feminist criminological theories which claim bias against women in our criminal justice system. This is NOT the case here; if anything women got more lenient treatment. (See middle, p. 187)
#12 "Operational Parameters in the Stolen Property System"
A. Examines the property theft system (or business) from a marketing perspective -- such as the role of supply and demand.
B. Makes a very good point about how many studies have focused on the individual criminal apart from the social system with which he connects, which the authors contend is short-sighted. See especially p. 194 (almost the entire page which brings this point out well).
1. The authors get rather detailed about how this Stolen Propety System works, especially how the thief and the fence interact.
__________________________
That's all for now. Incorporate the above comments in your notes for the class. Also, only one family has turned in their two proposed short-answer questions (and answers). The rest of the families need to do that soon. By next Tuesday (11/4), if at all possible. I will be adding some concluding comments on Crime Types as a whole, probably on Tuesday 11/11.
First, my comments on Chapter 7 which I did not get to yesterday in class:
#16 "Drugs-Crime Connections: Elaborations from the Life Histories of Hard Core Heroin Addicts"
A. Looks at the basic question: do drugs cause crime or does crime cause drugs?
1. Basically, addicts said their drug and criminal activities began independently, but eventually became intertwined, which makes sense.
B. Two general factors shape the drug and crime careers of respondents: (1) availability -- more you had, more you did; less available it was most addicts could adjust by reducing consumption. (2) life-structure -- "...regularly occuring patterns of daily domestic, occupational, recreational, or criminal activity."
C. The article makes an important point about when heroin becomes the most destructive -- when that larger "life-structure" is deteriorated. See middle paragraph on p. 274, under heading: The Free-Wheeling Junkie -- High Availability/Low Life Structure.
D. We must seek to improve that life structure -- sense of order and purpose -- to rehabilitate the heroin addict.
#17 "The Miami Sex-for-Crack Market Revisited"
A. No question that prostitution and crack cocaine use are related. Also includes a public health warning about having sex in some of these crack houses -- that they are at extreme risk of contracting HIV.
#18 "An Analysis of Women's Involvement in Prostitution"
A. This is an unpublished paper which I believe is poorly written, filled with jargon, and based on only 21 interviews.
B. One interesting point which was touched on in the class report is the irony of fining these women for their behavior. "Fining women involved in prostitution for their prostitution-related offenses is paradoxical. Many of them simply did not have the financial resources to pay their fines. The obvious irony is that the criminal justice system, itself, created the conditions that both justified these women's continued involvement in prostitution as well as trapped them within it" (p. 296)
Chapter 5 Burglary
A. Recent NCVS data suggest that crimes against property account for more than three-fourths of all criminal victimizations, and roughly one in six property crimes is a household burglary. Estimates indicate that 3,139,700 households were burglarized in 2001. Total of $2.9 billion in losses, not to mention the emotional trauma of the victims.
1. Yet the rate of burglary has dropped nearly 75% over the past three decades. In 1973 there were 110 per 1,000 households compared to 28.7 per 1,000 in 2001.
2. Perhaps surprisingly, the rural rate is higher than the suburban rate, which is the lowest. This is probably due to greater prevalence of neighborhood watch programs, more police patrols, in suburban areas. This lends credence to the routine activities theory. (see bottom, p. 172)
3. Also surprising, this is one crime where the U.S. compares favorably with many other countries. (see top, p. 173)
B. A significant point is that this type of crime also depends on a thriving UNDERGROUND ECONOMY, consisting of FENCES (people willing to handle stolen goods) and consumers willing to buy this stolen merchandise. (Flea markets are notorious for being places where stolen goods are sold.)
C. Under the "cognitive aspects of burglary," Dabney notes the "shallow instrumental motives" -- burglars become accustomed to a fast-paced lifestyle and/or are addicted to drugs "thus (they) continue to commit burglaries in the face of increasing risks and diminishing rewards." (p. 176)
1. Although obviously some planning is involved -- "Research indicates that most burglars engage in only minimal pre-event planning....Indeed, they tend to operate in a somewhat spontaneous fashion, exploiting opportunities as they arise." (p. 177)
2. 56% of incarcerated burglars in one survey were under the influence of drugs or alcohol at the time they committed their last offense. But a urinalysis of arrested offenders found 80% to have drugs or alcohol in their system.
a) Some use drugs to enhance their performance (botttom, p. 178), such as Malcolm X who talked about snorting cocaine before going out to burglarize.
3. Burglars tend to depend on others such as getting inside information about whether a home is vacant or what valuables might be in a home.
D. Arrest rate is only 13% (which might suggest the relevance of deterrence theory since the certainty of punishment in so low).
E. Informal controls (eg., neighborhood crime watch) are important to deter burglary activity. Even neighbors just getting together to clean up their neighborhood might send a deterrence message to would-be burglars.
#11 "A Woman's Place Is in the Home: Females and Residential Burglary"
A. Profiles female burglars who share a lot of the characteristics with males, but in some cases even more so -- eg., that they almost always work with others. Also, women tend to start at an older age than males.
B. Confirms an observation I made about feminist criminological theories which claim bias against women in our criminal justice system. This is NOT the case here; if anything women got more lenient treatment. (See middle, p. 187)
#12 "Operational Parameters in the Stolen Property System"
A. Examines the property theft system (or business) from a marketing perspective -- such as the role of supply and demand.
B. Makes a very good point about how many studies have focused on the individual criminal apart from the social system with which he connects, which the authors contend is short-sighted. See especially p. 194 (almost the entire page which brings this point out well).
1. The authors get rather detailed about how this Stolen Propety System works, especially how the thief and the fence interact.
__________________________
That's all for now. Incorporate the above comments in your notes for the class. Also, only one family has turned in their two proposed short-answer questions (and answers). The rest of the families need to do that soon. By next Tuesday (11/4), if at all possible. I will be adding some concluding comments on Crime Types as a whole, probably on Tuesday 11/11.
Wednesday, October 29, 2008
ESSAY II DESCRIPTION
Below is a description of what I want you to do for the next short essay assignment. I will not be handing out a hard copy of this assignment.
Sociology 220
Essay II
10/29/08
A. On Tuesday, November 4th (election day) I will be showing a documentary entitled, "A Hard Straight," which chronicles the struggles of three parolees. For this essay I want you to focus on ONE of these three parolees. Briefly describe this person's situation and then discuss what you believe could have been done to help this person make a successful transition to life outside of prison. Let me recommend that you jot down some notes while seeing the video so that you can incorporate some details in your essay and not just write in "vague generalities." IT IS IMPORTANT THAT YOU MAKE EVERY EFFORT TO BE IN CLASS ON THE 4TH TO SEE THIS DOCUMENTARY. Following the showing of it I will return it to the library, so if you did miss it you would be able to check it out.
B. The essay should be roughly 2-3 pages.
C. It is due on TUES., NOV. 11TH, and it is worth 25 points.
Sociology 220
Essay II
10/29/08
A. On Tuesday, November 4th (election day) I will be showing a documentary entitled, "A Hard Straight," which chronicles the struggles of three parolees. For this essay I want you to focus on ONE of these three parolees. Briefly describe this person's situation and then discuss what you believe could have been done to help this person make a successful transition to life outside of prison. Let me recommend that you jot down some notes while seeing the video so that you can incorporate some details in your essay and not just write in "vague generalities." IT IS IMPORTANT THAT YOU MAKE EVERY EFFORT TO BE IN CLASS ON THE 4TH TO SEE THIS DOCUMENTARY. Following the showing of it I will return it to the library, so if you did miss it you would be able to check it out.
B. The essay should be roughly 2-3 pages.
C. It is due on TUES., NOV. 11TH, and it is worth 25 points.
Comments on Chapter 4
Below are my follow-up comments on Chapter 4: Robbery. Again, keep in mind that if I ask any questions about this chapter in addition to the ones the family submits, they will come from these follow-up comments.
Chapter 4: Robbery
A. This crime is underreported. The NCVS indicates that roughly 40% of robbery victims chose not to notify the police.
B. "As is the case with all forms of violent crime, increased population density yields significantly higher robbery victimization rates."
city -- 4.9 per 1,000 residents
suburban -- 2.2 per 1,000
rural -- 1.4 per 1,000 (p. 131)
(which, as I noted in class, generally supports social disorganization theory)
C. Researchers found that "injuries occurred far less frequently in robberies involving a gun than they did when a knife, club, or no weapon was present." (p. 132)
D. Robbery is different from other violent crimes in that the vast majority of robbery offenders and victims do NOT know each other.
E. Very high recidivism rate -- 70.% re-arrested within three years of release from prison.
F. Many robbers commit their crimes while under the influence of drugs and/or alcohol -- one-third or more.
G."Planning does not appear to play a large role in most robberies." they may be described as "alert opportunists" for the most part. (p. 136)
H. Most "seasoned thieves" invoke some normative neutralizations to justify their behavior. Again, we see the relevance of "techniques of neutralization."
I. Dabney identifies the existence of a criminal subculture where other robbers are known as "colleagues" or they act as conspirators, or in teams. (suggesting the relevance of differential association theory)
#9 "Stick-up, Street Culture, and Offender Motivation"
A. In addition to the obvious motivation of a need for money, the authors talk about the larger culture in which they exist which is driven by the need to spend to fit in, seek pleasure in a harsh world, "life as a party" instant gratification. They are so focused on gratification, there is little consideration of consequences, often little effort at planning. (which generally runs contrary to rational choice or deterrence theory.
B. P. 146 beginning with "Without doubt,...." about the middle of the page and continuing all the way to the end of that page, Dabney captures well the world of these criminals. In some respects, one can see the relevance of anomie theory. Even though most of them do not necessarily face economic hardships, they feel the pressure to keep up with the fast-paced "life as party" lifestyle and so resort to illegitimate means to achieve that.
C. Later, Dabney says, "... the 'choice' to rob occurs in a context in which rationality not only is sharply bounded, it barely exists." (p. 148) Which, again, raises a question about the relevance of rational choice theory.
#10 "Dubs and Dees, Beats and Rims, Carjackers and Urban Violence"
A. From the abstract: "Offenders may choose to engage in the crime in response to peer pressure, boredom, or a perceived need for money, drugs, or transportation." (p. 149) reflecting the possible application of both differential association and social bonding theory, in which I interjected my "boredom theory" in the context of talking about Hirschi's bond of Involvement.
B. Underscores the lack of planning, impulsiveness often stemming from a desperate need for drugs.
C. Notes how easy targets sometimes motivated carjackers -- isolated, weak victims, desirable vehicles. See bottom of p.154-155, which suggests a calculation of greater pleasure or gain, which lends itself to rational choice theory. I would also add, routine activities theory as relevant.
D. But to counter-balance the above point about the relevance of rational choice: the thing that strikes me about alot of these interviews is that these carjackers are so focused on satisfying immediate "needs" or pleasures, that nothing else matters. There is no conception or thought of how such a lifestyle is a complete dead end no matter how successful they may be in the short run.
That's it for now. Look for my comments on Chapter 5 later (perhaps Friday). Also, I will be posting a description of our next short essay assignment soon, connected with viewing the documentary, "A Hard Straight" which I will be showing in class next Tuesday, 11/4.
Chapter 4: Robbery
A. This crime is underreported. The NCVS indicates that roughly 40% of robbery victims chose not to notify the police.
B. "As is the case with all forms of violent crime, increased population density yields significantly higher robbery victimization rates."
city -- 4.9 per 1,000 residents
suburban -- 2.2 per 1,000
rural -- 1.4 per 1,000 (p. 131)
(which, as I noted in class, generally supports social disorganization theory)
C. Researchers found that "injuries occurred far less frequently in robberies involving a gun than they did when a knife, club, or no weapon was present." (p. 132)
D. Robbery is different from other violent crimes in that the vast majority of robbery offenders and victims do NOT know each other.
E. Very high recidivism rate -- 70.% re-arrested within three years of release from prison.
F. Many robbers commit their crimes while under the influence of drugs and/or alcohol -- one-third or more.
G."Planning does not appear to play a large role in most robberies." they may be described as "alert opportunists" for the most part. (p. 136)
H. Most "seasoned thieves" invoke some normative neutralizations to justify their behavior. Again, we see the relevance of "techniques of neutralization."
I. Dabney identifies the existence of a criminal subculture where other robbers are known as "colleagues" or they act as conspirators, or in teams. (suggesting the relevance of differential association theory)
#9 "Stick-up, Street Culture, and Offender Motivation"
A. In addition to the obvious motivation of a need for money, the authors talk about the larger culture in which they exist which is driven by the need to spend to fit in, seek pleasure in a harsh world, "life as a party" instant gratification. They are so focused on gratification, there is little consideration of consequences, often little effort at planning. (which generally runs contrary to rational choice or deterrence theory.
B. P. 146 beginning with "Without doubt,...." about the middle of the page and continuing all the way to the end of that page, Dabney captures well the world of these criminals. In some respects, one can see the relevance of anomie theory. Even though most of them do not necessarily face economic hardships, they feel the pressure to keep up with the fast-paced "life as party" lifestyle and so resort to illegitimate means to achieve that.
C. Later, Dabney says, "... the 'choice' to rob occurs in a context in which rationality not only is sharply bounded, it barely exists." (p. 148) Which, again, raises a question about the relevance of rational choice theory.
#10 "Dubs and Dees, Beats and Rims, Carjackers and Urban Violence"
A. From the abstract: "Offenders may choose to engage in the crime in response to peer pressure, boredom, or a perceived need for money, drugs, or transportation." (p. 149) reflecting the possible application of both differential association and social bonding theory, in which I interjected my "boredom theory" in the context of talking about Hirschi's bond of Involvement.
B. Underscores the lack of planning, impulsiveness often stemming from a desperate need for drugs.
C. Notes how easy targets sometimes motivated carjackers -- isolated, weak victims, desirable vehicles. See bottom of p.154-155, which suggests a calculation of greater pleasure or gain, which lends itself to rational choice theory. I would also add, routine activities theory as relevant.
D. But to counter-balance the above point about the relevance of rational choice: the thing that strikes me about alot of these interviews is that these carjackers are so focused on satisfying immediate "needs" or pleasures, that nothing else matters. There is no conception or thought of how such a lifestyle is a complete dead end no matter how successful they may be in the short run.
That's it for now. Look for my comments on Chapter 5 later (perhaps Friday). Also, I will be posting a description of our next short essay assignment soon, connected with viewing the documentary, "A Hard Straight" which I will be showing in class next Tuesday, 11/4.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)