Something to think about: why do you think the FBI does not vouch for the accuracy of the statistics it publishes in The Uniform Crime Reports?
Please comment on this question or the comments of your classmates.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
21 comments:
I believe that the FBI doesnt vouch for the unified crime reports because they are not at all accurate. I believe that some crimes, reported or not, are committed but never recorded. An example is that if you get a speeding ticket (which can be reported), sometimes it is dropped by the officer. The crime was still committed but it was never officially marked down. I believe that the FBI doesn't want to be accountable for false information. This is just a way of having them not take the heat for the crimes being committed and recorded.
I agree that the FBI does not vouch for the accuracy of its crime statistics because there are offenses that are reported but not carried out, along with some that are not reported at all. The FBI doesn't want to put its name on something unless they know for sure that its correct. -Mike McDonnell
I agree that the FBI does not say that they have an accurate crime statistic because they cannot account for all the crimes that go un documented, such as minor theft and rapes gone unreported. The FBI is just the collector of data from all police stations and even in some cases police departments doen't always file reports.
I don't think the FBI vouches for statistics because they don't really know. Since so many crimes are never reported, either by the victim or the police officer, they don't feel comfortable telling the public unrealistic statistics. Also, they must know that a lot of crimes aren't recorded, so they don't want to claim they have information that they don't actually have.
The FBI does not vouch for the accuracy of the UCR’s because they are simply the body that compiles the statistics. They neither record nor investigate (typically) the crimes being reported. As other students have mentioned there is a large percentage of crimes that go unreported. The victims are either too scared or apathetic to come forward. Individual police stations/ districts are responsible for compiling their own statistics and sending them to the FBI. This process involves several steps and many people handle the data which increases the likelihood that and error could be made. It is very hard to get every police department to compile and record their data in the same manner and even when this is attempted it is impossible to enforce. Overall the UCR does not always contain the most reliable information and therefore the FBI does not want to take the chance that they could be blamed for these inaccuracies.
I think the FBI doesn't vouch for the crime stats because in all honesty they do not know. The police departments do not send in accurate reports of the crimes not only because they are too lazy to report them but also because many people do not report crimes that they were involved in or that they witnessed. It is impossible to have perfect stats about America's crime rate because no one knows for sure. It is sad to know that no one knows the exact crime rate that happens in our own country.
The FBI doesn't vouch for UCR data because the department understands that information can be easily misinterpreted and ultimately reported incorrectly. This time the federal government plays it safe and admits when it can be wrong. This massive flurry of information from all across America becomes scrambled and yes, wrong information will eventually be produced. Instead of being confronted by another party with conflicting stats (some that may turn out to be better handled and closer to fact), the FBI takes responsibility out of the matter altogether. If they did the exact opposite, by claiming every published line is true, the Bureau would become more and more irrelevant in future scenarios of their undertaking.
I believe that the FBI does not vouch for the accuracy of the UCR reports because they get these reports from local precincts. There is no way for the FBI to investigate every precinct's accuracy of reporting crimes especially with the problems associated with reporting crimes in general (failure to file, failure to report, etc). Imagine the man power needed by the FBI to undertake such an endeavor.
The FBI does not vouch for the accuracy of the UCR because they do not want to rely too heavily on local level law enforcement. There are places where local sheriffs departments are very corrupt and the agenda of the officers is unknown. Sometimes officers could care less about what the report at the end of the day. Therefore the FBI does not want to be held accountable.
I agree with all posts, however, not knowing too much (yet) about crime statistics it seems that the FBI should vouch for the UCR as being at best a minimum for the amount crimes being committed. Also like some of the other posts mentioned, some crimes are too trivial or too traumatic for victims to report.
I believe the FBI does not vouch for its statistics mostly because they can not vouch for the integrity of every police department. Some police officers are more lenient towards offenders because they do not want to write up all the paper work, where as others are stricter.
I agree with all comments posted so far. However, I also believe the FBI doesn't vouch for the accuracy of its statistics since not all crimes are reported and if they are reported, they aren't always accurate.Hopefully though, a margin of error is included. Some reports might also contain altered data to make a certain area feel safer.
It is my understanding that the UCR is not completely accurate and it varies from precinct to precint. Hence, the FBI, when they come together cannot vouch for the UCR because of the technicalities of the different rules h ence the individual reports are not accurate enough for the FBI to support. The FBI does not want to be accountalbe for information that they believe can be false due to miscalculations...Ex: Many crimes are not reported.
I agree with all of the aforementioned reasons. If the FBI were to legitimize the UCR it may cause more attention to be paid to statistics that could create a false sense of security or fear.
The FBI doesnt vouch for the unified crime reports because they are not true.
One possible reason for the FBI's decision not to vouch for the information supplied in the unified crime reports might be that, in doing so they leave themselves the ability to manipulate the information in a manner that would allow them to paint themselves, as well as their practices, in the best light possible.
I think that the FBI does not vouch for the statistics it produces because they know that the stats are not accurate and that they can never be accurately reported. which leads me to the question of why they attempt to continue to produce these facts?
I believe that the FBI does not have accurate statistics because of the laziness. Alot of police officers dont even take the time to write someone up because of all the paper work, especially with smaller crimes. For this reason it is very hard to keep legitimate statistics.
I believe that the FBI doesn't support the crime reports because they know that there are many crimes unaccounted for and not reported. Often times I feel the FBI tries to keep their name out of many crime reports because if it is a valid report they don't want their name involved. Main point is that there are so many crimes committed daily that there is not way they all can be reported, so that is why the FBI doesn't vouch for the crime reports.
I agree with all the reasons listed but another reason is that they acknowledge that even if police stations were keeping excellent records it would still not be enough. There are too many instances of crimes being committed without being reported or sometimes even noticed.
Post a Comment